March 3, Kohima: Members of the Nagaland Legislative Assembly today strongly opposed the playing of the National Song, "Vande Mataram," on the first day of the 8th Session of the State Assembly, citing concerns under Article 371(A) of the Constitution.
Initiating the discussion on the Motion of Thanks to the Governor's Address, MLA Kuzholuzo Nienu termed the inclusion of "Vande Mataram" in the Assembly proceedings as "completely unnecessary."
He argued that the song, which references a Hindu goddess, could be seen as conflicting with secular principles in a Christian-majority state like Nagaland.
He maintained that its inclusion constitutes a violation of Article 371(A), which grants special constitutional protections to the Naga people.
Limaonen Chang of RPI-Athawale also expressed surprise at the playing of the National Song during the Assembly session.
NPF MLA P. Longon echoed similar sentiments, stating that he feels the song is being imposed upon members.
Mr. Longon called upon members to invoke the provision under Article 371(A), which stipulates that no Act of Parliament shall apply to Naga religious or social practices, customary law, civil and criminal justice, or land and resource ownership unless the State Assembly resolves to accept it.
He urged the House to either resolve to accept or reject the inclusion of the National Song before the National Anthem in future Assembly sessions.
Participating in the discussion, Minister Temjen Imna Along reminded the House that "Vande Mataram" was adopted by the Constituent Assembly of India in 1950 and must be understood in its historical context, particularly during India's struggle against British rule. He said the song symbolized the emotions and resistance of that era.
Highlighting India's diversity, Mr. Along said that while individuals may hold personal opinions, it is important to respect the sentiments attached to the National Song by a large section of the population.
Describing himself as a Christian, he shared his experience of studying in Christian schools where people of different faiths participated in prayers as a mark of mutual respect. He emphasized that secularism means accepting and respecting each other’s beliefs.
Minister Along urged members not to view the National Song as an infringement on their faith, but to regard it as a national symbol deserving due respect whenever it is sung.
MLA Achumbemo disagreed with the argument of Minister Along and said that imposing the National song is a complete violation of the fundamental rights guaranteed to citizens and contrary to the fundamental duties enshrined in the Constitution of India.
The legislator urged the House to pass an order deemed appropriate by the Chair, making it clear that both the Assembly and the people of Nagaland are not in a position to accept this imposition.
MLAs Dr Neisato Mero, Dr Tseilhouto Rutso, T N Manen and Jwenga Tep also echoed similar resentment over the inclusion of "Vande Mataram."